Best Finish For Hardwood Floors With Dogs: 5 Best options

Tim de JongWritten by Tim de Jong
9 min read
Best Finish For Hardwood Floors With Dogs: 5 Best options
#1 Best Pick
RUST-OLEUM Premium Polyurethane Finish

RUST-OLEUM Premium Polyurethane Finish

Check Price

The best finish for hardwood floors with dogs is a hard-wearing polyurethane, either oil-based or water-based, in a satin or matte sheen, because it resists scratches and moisture and hides the marks that do appear far better than gloss. Our top pick is the Rust-Oleum Premium Polyurethane Finish, with Duraseal as the budget choice and Rust-Oleum Diamond as the best water-based option.

Dogs are important family members, but their nails, toys and occasional accidents can take a toll on wood floors. No finish makes a floor completely scratch-proof, but the right one makes a big difference.

Whether you’re revamping old floors or protecting new ones, the varieties of hardwood finishes available can cause confusion. Hopefully, this post will help you make an informed decision.

Best Finish for Hardwood Floors with Dogs

We’ve done some research on various products in the market that can ensure durability and stand the test of time. Here are our top picks for hardwood floor finishes:

At a glance

5 picks, each best at something different

1RUST-OLEUM Premium Polyurethane Finish

Best overall
RUST-OLEUM Premium Polyurethane Finish
Durability
5
Easy to use
5
Longevity
5
Total value
4.6
Check Price on Amazon

One of the best of its kind, Rust-Oleum Oil Polyurethane is a premium choice on our list. Although expensive, this product is excellent for giving your floor a protective coating. If budget isn’t a concern, we highly recommend picking this over others.

Rust-Oleum Oil Polyurethane is thickly formulated and packed with features that make it suitable for heavy use. It can take a while to dry down because of its thickness, but humidity and temperature dramatically determine the drying time.

This premium hardwood floor finish gives your floor a rich, satiny, and durable finish. It does not soak too deep into the floor, and its odor is milder than many oil-based finishes. That said, any oil-based finish releases fumes while it cures, so ventilate well and keep pets and children out of the room.

Disclaimer: You might not like this product if you already have a pre-treated floor.

Pros

  • Gives a durable and shiny finish
  • Doesn’t have a strong, pungent smell
  • Enhances the wood grain and gives a satin finish
  • You don’t need a lot of this product as it needs minimal coating

Cons

  • More on the expensive side compared to other products
  • Doesn’t work well on pre-treated surfaces.

2Duraseal Polyurethane clear Oil-Based Finish

Best for budget
Duraseal Polyurethane clear Oil-Based Finish
Durability
4.5
Easy to use
5
Longevity
4.5
Total value
4.6
Check Price on Amazon

Another oil-based hardwood floor finish that promises durability and protection against scratches is this one from Duraseal.

Duraseal is a trusted brand for providing hardwood floor finishes, and this product is among the best in the market. You can rely on it to make your floor more scratch-resistant. It is a transparent product that deepens and enhances the wood’s color. Since it is oil-based, it prevents dirt and spills from permeating the wood.

The best part about this product is that you can choose different types of finishes based on your preference- satin, gloss, semi-gloss, and matte. You can also purchase it in 1, 2.5, and 5-gallon sizes.

The product takes about 8 hours to dry. You wouldn’t require a professional to do the job as it is pretty easy to use with clear instructions included on the label. One gallon of this product offers coverage up to 500 sq. ft. Therefore, it is a cost-effective option if you don’t want to spend a fortune on a hardwood floor finish.

Pros

  • Offers resistance to scratches and dents
  • Gives the wood a rich and deep color
  • Available in multiple sizes and finishes
  • It provides excellent coverage

Cons

  • You may need to apply multiple coats for the best results and durability
  • It takes a long time to dry

3RUST-OLEUM Diamond Floor Finish

Best water-based formula
RUST-OLEUM Diamond Floor Finish
Durability
4.8
Easy to use
4.8
Longevity
4.7
Total value
4.6
Check Price on Amazon

Those who aren’t into oil-based formulae will find this finish better. The Rust-Oleum Waterborne Diamond floor finish offers a glossy crystal-clear finish to your hardwood floors and shields them from scratches and dents.

This hardwood floor finish is made for high-traffic areas, so it copes well even if your house is a den! It provides strong protection from scuffs and abrasion.

Kudos to the chemical and stain-resistant formula; dog vomit or urine won’t soak straight into the wood as long as you wipe it up promptly. Puddles left to sit for hours can still damage any finish. It is an excellent product that ensures durability and wood grain preservation.

Since this product is water-based, it takes very little time to dry. You can recoat your floor on the same day, unlike other times when you have to wait for 24 hours for the second coating.

Another advantage of using the Rust-Oleum Waterborne Diamond floor finish is that sanding is not required between coats. It only requires a waiting time of 1 hour after the first coat to apply the second time.

Pros

  • It allows re-coating on the same day
  • Dries into a crystal-clear durable finish
  • Sanding isn’t needed between coats
  • Offers durability and high resistance to chemicals and stains

Cons

  • It has a slight smell

4Zar Semi Gloss Interior Ultra Polyurethane

Best self-leveling
Zar Semi Gloss Interior Ultra Polyurethane
Durability
4.8
Easy to use
5
Longevity
4.6
Total value
4.8
Check Price on Amazon

If looking at brush strokes after painting something is a pet peeve, you surely wouldn’t like to see it on your floor when you give it a finish. This semi-gloss hard floor finish from Zar ensures that you get a smooth application.

It has a self-leveling feature that gives your wood floor a smooth, streak-free coating. Since it dries within an hour and a half to two hours after the initial coat, you can get the work done quickly.

There are no problems with the Zar semi-gloss finish regarding durability. You’ll notice far fewer scratches from your dog’s nails once you coat your floor with this finish.

The main downside is its very smooth finish, which can make floors slippery. That matters for dogs, especially seniors or dogs with joint problems, so add a few rugs or runners in the areas where your dog walks, turns and plays.

Pros

  • Dries fast and self-levels
  • It is affordable
  • Gives a durable and abrasion-resistant finish

Cons

  • It does not darken the hardwood floor

5Deft Lacquer Sanding Sealer Spray

Best durable spray finish
Deft Lacquer Sanding Sealer Spray
Durability
4.8
Easy to use
5
Longevity
4.6
Total value
4.8
Check Price on Amazon

The Deft Lacquer Sanding Sealer Spray is a handy option for smaller jobs, such as touching up worn spots, thresholds, stair edges or wooden trim your dog keeps scratching.

With 100% nitrocellulose in its formula, this spray hardens quickly from the first layer. Keep in mind that it is a sanding sealer: it seals the wood and gives the topcoat something to grip, so for a whole floor you’ll still want a floor-grade polyurethane over it. An aerosol can also isn’t practical for covering an entire room.

A coat of the Deft lacquer spray helps keep moisture and stains from getting into the wood. You can lightly sand and apply a second coat for a smoother texture. Fortunately, the spray doesn’t harden or discolor inside the can even if you store it away for a long time.

The Deft lacquer spray dries in about half an hour and doesn’t leave a tacky finish. Expect to sand lightly after the first coat, as it can leave a slightly rough texture.

Pros

  • Hardens quickly after the first application
  • Multiple coating is not necessary
  • Does not discolor over time
  • Easy to use and effortless to sand

Cons

  • Given its price, the spray quantity is a little small

Conclusion – Best Finish for Hardwood Floors with Dogs

Protecting your hardwood floor by coating it with a durable finish is crucial to make it long-lasting. As a pet owner, you would know better about the damage they can cause to unprotected hardwood floors over time. Therefore, it is vital to give your floor a protective layer. Keeping your dog's nails short with one of the best nail files for dogs also prevents a lot of scratches (and helps quiet dog nails on the floor).

We have listed our top five picks of the best hardwood floor finishes. You can pick a suitable one for your home based on your budget and preference. Once you give your floor a coat or two of these finishes, scratches and wear will be much easier to keep at bay. For day-to-day cleaning afterward, use a soft broom for dog hair on hardwood floors so you don't scratch the new finish.

Found this helpful?
Best Finish For Hardwood Floors With Dogs: 5 Best options